Historical: Men’s Team of the Year Award
| 2017 | Massey White Rugby Team | Rugby |
| 2016 | Varsity Men’s Rugby Team | Rugby |
| 2015 | Massey University Division One Men’s Hockey Team | Hockey |
| 2014 | Massey University Division One Men’s Hockey Team | Hockey |
| 2013 | Massey University Division One Men’s Hockey Team | Hockey |
| 2012 | Massey University Division One Men’s Hockey Team | Hockey |
| 2011 | Massey Varsity A Rugby Team | Rugby |
| 2010 | Massey Varsity A Rugby Team | Rugby |
| 2009 | Not Awarded | |
| 2008 | Massey Rams | Rugby |
| 2007 | Massey Colts | Rugby |
| 2006 | Massey Colts | Rugby |
| 2005 | Varsity Blues | Hockey |
Historical: Women’s Team of the Year Award
| 2017 | Massey A1 Netball Team | Netball |
| Massey Women’s 1st XI Football Team | Football | |
| 2016 | Massey Netball Team | Netball |
| 2015 | Massey Women’s 1st XI Football Team | Football |
| 2014 | Massey Women’s 1st XI Football Team | Football |
| 2013 | Massey University Division One Women’s Hockey Team | Hockey |
| 2012 | Massey University Women’s Football Team | Football |
| 2011 | Massey Women’s Basketball Team | Basketball |
| 2010 | Not Awarded | |
| 2009 | Not Awarded | |
| 2008 | Massey Women’s Volleyball Team | Volleyball |
| 2007 | Not Awarded | |
| 2006 | Not Awarded | |
| 2005 | Massey Women’s Volleyball Team | Volleyball |